A long-standing practice regarding pay raises did not constitute a legally binding custom
In a labor arbitration award dated 12 October, 2026, it was held that a company’s long-standing practice of implementing pay raises on 1 March was not, in and of itself, sufficient to establish a binding custom. The arbitrator also found that an unsigned document from 2017 had not been proven to constitute a final, concluded local agreement.
Disagreement Regarding the Effective Date of the Pay Increase
The case concerned whether unskilled employees at AVK International A/S were entitled, pursuant to a local agreement or established custom, to back pay for the period from 1 March to 30 April 2025.
Until 2016, the company had a local agreement dating from 2000 regarding the conduct of wage negotiations and the effective date of wage increases stipulating back pay from 1 March. In November 2016, the company terminated all local agreements and customary practices, and the arbitrator found that the employees’ side accepted the termination. The local agreement from 2000 was therefore no longer in effect. On 10 March 2017, a new document was drafted, according to which the intention was for wage increases to take effect on 1 March. The document was supposed to be signed by three people but was not signed by any of them.
During the 2025 wage negotiations, a disagreement arose regarding the effective date. The company, on its own initiative, paid a wage increase of 3.75 kr. per hour effective May 1, 2025, while the employee side demanded that the wage increase take effect on 1 March.
CO-industri argued that the employees were entitled to a wage adjustment effective 1 March based on the 2017 local agreement, or alternatively, the 2000 local agreement or a binding custom. DI Overenskomst I contested this and argued, among other things, that the 2017 document was merely a draft, that the 2000 local agreement had been validly terminated, and that the effective date in each year had been the result of negotiations.
An unsigned local agreement was not binding
The arbitrator first had to determine whether the 2000 local agreement remained in effect and whether the March 2017 document could be considered a binding local agreement.
The arbitrator found that the 2000 local agreement had been validly terminated in 2016, as the employee side had accepted the termination.
With regard to the 2017 document, the arbitrator determined that, as a general rule, a local agreement does not require a signature to be valid.
However, the arbitrator emphasized that the other local agreements, which had been entered into after the termination in 2016 and were considered valid, had all been signed. It was therefore upon CO-industri to prove that the unsigned document constituted a final agreement.
Since no sufficiently reliable explanation for the missing signature had emerged during the presentation of evidence, the arbitrator found that CO-industri had not met the burden of proof that a binding local agreement had been concluded.
Established practice regarding wage increases did not constitute a legally binding custom
The arbitrator then had to determine if a legally binding custom had been established following the 2016 termination, whereby wage increases were to take effect on 1 March.
All pay increases for unskilled employees after 2016 had taken effect on 1 March, except for the pay increase in 2025.
However, the arbitrator found that CO-industri had not demonstrated that the employees had reason to believe the effective date was the result of a legal obligation on the company's part. Emphasis was placed on the limited number of wage negotiations since 2016 and the wording of the agreements, which implied that the effective date of the wage increases was also the result of negotiations between the parties.
The arbitrator emphasized that an agreement on wage increases effective 1 May had been reached for skilled employees in 2025 and that CO-industri did not argue that different practices applied to skilled and unskilled employees.
Finally, the arbitrator concluded that the 2017 document supported this view. The document merely stated that the outcome of the negotiations was intended to take effect on 1 March. This argument contradicts the idea that the company should have considered itself legally obligated to grant wage increases effective as of that date.
Based on this, the arbitrator found that a binding custom had not been established and that the employer should not back pay the salary from 1 March.
Littler notes
The ruling shows that having a consistent practice for the effective date of pay increases does not automatically create a legally binding custom. Whether wage increases have taken effect on the same date for a number of years is not the only decisive factor; it must also be determined whether the effective date reflected a legal obligation on the part of the employer or was merely the result of annual wage negotiations.
The ruling also confirms that a signature is not a prerequisite for the validity of a local agreement where it is clear that the parties were in agreement when entering into the agreement. However, the absence of a signature may have significant evidentiary value where the parties subsequently disagree. Especially when other local agreements drafted and deemed valid during the same period were signed. In this case, none of the witnesses could explain why the 2017 document was not signed.
At Littler, we regularly advise employers on collective bargaining agreements, local agreements, legally binding customs, and other complex employment law issues.
You can contact us here.
Disclaimer: The above is not, and cannot replace, legal advice.
Reference to the judgment: https://arbejdsretten.dk/media/xb5hbhhq/fv2026-166.pdf
____________________________________________

Stephan Gheysen
Attorney & Partner
+45 27 21 05 06